Nobody has strong feelings about dhaniya. It is the quiet ingredient that makes up the body of a masala, and precisely because nobody thinks about it, it is where the cheating happens.
Short answer: Coriander is the base of most Indian spice blends by volume - often a third or more - which makes it both the most important one to buy well and the most common target for bulking the powder with husk and sawdust.

Why it is the base of everything
Coriander is mild. That is the point. It has a gentle citrus-and-wood flavour that does not compete with anything, and it has bulk - which means it can carry the assertive spices without diluting them into nothing.
In a garam masala, coriander is usually around a third of the weight. In a sambar powder it is often more. In a chana masala, a chaat masala, a rajma masala - the same story.
Which means if your dhaniya is poor, every blend you make is poor, and you will not be able to point at what is wrong. The clove will still taste like clove.

What good whole seed looks like
Pale tan to light brown, round, uniform in size, and strikingly light for its volume - coriander is mostly hollow, which is why a hundred grams looks like a lot.
Crush a few between your palms. The smell should be immediate: fresh, citrusy, slightly woody. Old coriander smells dusty and faintly of cardboard, which is precisely the taste it will give a masala.
Look at the lot for stalk fragments, stones and dust. Coriander is harvested in a way that picks up a lot of debris, and a clean lot has been properly winnowed.
Indian coriander is usually the smaller, rounder Eagle or Scotch variety; the larger Moroccan type is more common in Europe and is slightly less aromatic. Either is fine.

What goes into the powder
Coriander powder is widely bulked with coriander husk and bran - the parts left after the seed is processed - which is not dangerous and is not what you paid for. It is also sometimes stretched with starch or with sawdust, which is more clearly adulteration.
The home test is the water one: stir a teaspoon into a glass of water. Pure coriander powder floats initially and then settles slowly, leaving the water lightly coloured. Sawdust and husk float persistently and form a distinct scum; starch settles fast and leaves a white deposit.
It is a crude test and it catches the crude cases. The reliable answer, as with every powdered spice, is to buy the seed and grind it.
That is also the better answer for taste. Ground coriander is noticeably flat within two to three months, and most of what sits on a shelf is older than that.
Roasting, and dhana dal
Coriander is usually roasted before grinding for a masala - three to four minutes on a low flame, until it smells nutty and darkens slightly. It makes a real difference and it is quick.
Do not over-roast. Dark coriander turns bitter and takes the whole blend with it, and because it is a third of the weight there is nothing to hide behind.
Dhana dal is a different product: coriander seed split, skinned and roasted, sold as a mukhwas and used in chutneys and some south Indian masalas. It is mild, crunchy and faintly sweet - the gentlest thing on a mukhwas shelf and the one to give a child or anyone who finds saunf too strong.

Buying it in Salumbar
Our spices is on this site with the weight and the price on every pack. Order before 5 PM and it reaches you the same day inside Salumbar, free over ₹200. We have been on Sadar Bazar since 1961. If you would rather just say what you want, send it on WhatsApp and we will confirm the price before we pack anything.
Questions people ask
Should I buy coriander whole or ground?
Whole. Powder is flat within two to three months and is one of the most commonly bulked spice powders in India. Grinding takes a minute.
How do I check coriander powder?
Stir a teaspoon into water. Pure powder settles slowly and colours the water lightly; husk and sawdust float as a scum, and starch settles fast as a white deposit.
What is dhana dal?
Coriander seed split, skinned and roasted. It is used as a mild mukhwas and in chutneys and some south Indian masalas.
How much coriander in garam masala?
Usually around a third of the total weight. It is the body of the blend rather than a flavour note.
Should coriander be roasted before grinding?
Yes, three to four minutes on a low flame until it smells nutty. Do not let it darken much - over-roasted coriander is bitter and dominates.
How long does whole coriander keep?
Twelve to eighteen months airtight and away from heat. Ground, two to three months.